Northwest Horizons

The fate of Confederate statues

Silent Sam, a Confederate statue at UNC Chapel Hill was torn down in August 2018.  There has been a lot of controversy related to Confederate war memorials in North Carolina and the southern states.

Silent Sam, a Confederate statue at UNC Chapel Hill was torn down in August 2018. There has been a lot of controversy related to Confederate war memorials in North Carolina and the southern states.

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Protesters and supporters of the Winston-Salem Confederate statue gather at the corner of Fourth Street and Liberty Street for a rally on Jan. 13.  This is not an unusual sight for many in the South; Confederate statues throughout North Carolina and other southern states have been getting lots of attention after the Charlottesville riots resulted in the death of one person.  

   Today, many people are angry about the Confederate statue in Winston-Salem and the city has taken action to have it removed and relocated.  During the rally, protestors lined the streets with pickets signs saying, “From Winston-Salem to Chapel Hill, we don’t honor those that kill,” and “Take it down.”  

   “I think they should take down the statue because it is offensive to the people,” Sophomore Madeline Waterfield said.

   Many protestors agree with Waterfield.  Many see it as a way for southerners to promote racism and white supremacy, things that Waterfield says should not exist.

   “They’re promoting white supremacy and racism because people shouldn’t want that to be their Southern heritage,” Waterfield said, “It’s not like there’s something wrong about embracing Southern heritage, it’s just that you want it to embrace what it means to who you are.”

   However, as always, there are two sides to any debate.  Can there be an alternative to tearing down these statues?  Is there another way southerners can remember the fallen soldiers? Social studies teacher Ray Parrish thinks so.  

   “I would just like to see a really good dialogue.  I could see (the statue) going down, I could see it staying up, I could see a middle ground where we put another statue; we put a good firm message because part of the history is the protest and so there could be something there saying the history of this statue,” Parrish said, “It would be how (the statue) came up, protests were launched ‘here,’ and when you go through a historical area, they have a sign or a memorial; you’re kind of learning history as your going through this.”

   As Parrish states, there is a way to still learn about these statues and their history and also be aware of the pain it holds for others living in the south.  

I think they should be taken down so we can help to heal the wounds that still exist from slavery and from years and years after that of racism.”

— Waterfield

    However, for many people living in the south, protesting these statues and tearing them down is a big part in moving past the slavery and racism that has long been apparent in the south.  

   “I think they should be taken down so we can help to heal the wounds that still exist from slavery and from years and years after that of racism,” Waterfield said.

   This statement holds true for many people in the south who view removing these statues as a step in the right direction toward reversing the negative effects of slavery and racism.  Even more so, as Parrish mentions, a dialogue between the sides would be beneficial to reaching an agreement about Confederate statues throughout North Carolina and in the American South.

   “I’d love to see a really good discussion where people listen to others very well, where it’s not just for show or out of anger; I’ve really explored and I see all sides of it,” Parrish said, “I think the middle zone would be where they could have an honest discussion with each other, and eventually they could look at both sides.”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
1 Comment

One Response to “The fate of Confederate statues”

  1. Cyrus on January 17th, 2019 11:55 pm

    If people want to take down the statue because it’s offensive then I guess we’ll have to take everything down.

    Statues shouldn’t be torn down like this, without some kind of government permission. Even if what they fought for is a bad thing, they’re still a part of history. The statue is not condoning racism or slavery; it is not a problem.

    “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” In people’s drive to forget everything negative that’s ever happened they’re just going to end up repeating it.

    Also, why are these statues only a problem now? Why weren’t they a problem a few years ago. Why now? What’s changed between now and then?

    It also brings up the fact of why things like offensive books aren’t getting mass book burnings. (When these have happened before, people called others out on it. I don’t see how this and the statue issue is any different. People should be called out for this, too.)

    It feels to me people only need something to get upset about.

    Bringing up the historical value: I bet in 1000 or so years everyone in the future’s going to be mad at us because we were terrible at preserving our own history. I feel the same way when I hear of ancient civilizations destroying something to prove their dominance or whatever.

    Preserving history is more important then people’s feelings. History is forever, we are not.

Discuss the story here; your name and email are not required. All comments will be strictly moderated.




Northwest Horizons School News
The fate of Confederate statues